so anyway, this book is bizarre. it has some of the most disturbing things i've ever read, some very gruesome and some very chilling. it also has some very hokey cheesy parts. it has incredibly odd pacing -- the first 150 pgs or so, there were terrible things happening at a fairly rapid clip and the tension is enormous, then pretty much nothing happens for 100 pgs, and then the rest of the book goes totally off the wall. one of the most upsetting things i've ever read is immediately followed by something toothlessly over-the-top stupid. it didn't seem like comic relief or anything, so much as he wrote everything he possibly could, tossed it all in the air, and published it in whatever order it landed in. maybe he wrote it for nano!
summary: the writing is 90% clunky but very effective when it counts. his dialogue is laughable. it's not horror in the adrenaline/chills down your spine sense, it's disturbing. i've read a lot of crazy shit without getting phased, but this got to me again and again, and somehow it's very compelling for that. recommended if you want to be shuddering and cringing for the rest of the night.
edit: i'll also note that this book beat Scream to the meta punch. it came out a year earlier, and one of the main characters is an english professor who focuses on horror. so he knows all about the cliches and classic references, etc. it's never done tongue-in-cheek as scream though